Study Notes

Audit Materiality Notes: Performance Materiality and Tolerable Misstatement [CPA AUD]

Audit materiality diagram showing overall, performance and tolerable misstatement levels for CPA AUD

Think of audit materiality as the cut-off the auditor sets for how big an error must be before it could sway the choices of someone reading the statements. The auditor fixes that cut-off using judgment about what statement users need to know, then uses it when planning the work, when weighing errors found, and when deciding what opinion to give.

The hierarchy runs from overall materiality down to performance materiality, then tolerable misstatement for one account or sample, with clearly trivial amounts at the bottom. Use it with the other notes in the CPA notes hub to build the full AUD Area II picture.

What Audit Materiality Means Under AU-C 320

Audit materiality is the amount above which a misstatement could change a reasonable user decision. Performance materiality sits below overall materiality as a planning buffer. Tolerable misstatement applies performance materiality to one account or sample. Clearly trivial amounts sit at the bottom and stay off the schedule.

Under AU-C 320, an error is material when it could, alone or combined, sway statement users’ economic choices. The test covers errors and omissions alike.

The AICPA Blueprints effective January 2027 place materiality in AUD Area II, Assessing Risk and Developing a Planned Response, an area worth 25% to 35% of the section. The Blueprints give no separate weight for materiality on its own.

How Audit Materiality Is Set With Benchmarks

To fix overall materiality while planning, the auditor usually picks a base figure from the statements and applies a percentage to it. Profit before tax, revenue, assets and equity are the usual candidates. AU-C 320 prescribes no fixed percentage and no single benchmark.

Practice guides illustrate, without AU-C 320 prescribing any: about 5% of pre-tax income, usual range 3% to 7%; about 0.5% to 1% of revenue, usual range 0.5% to 2.0%; about 1% of total assets, usual range 0.5% to 2.0%; 1% to 5% of equity; and 0.5% to 2% of total expenses for a not-for-profit.

Worked Example A: Setting Overall Materiality for Harborline Manufacturing Co.

Harborline Manufacturing Co. is a privately held US manufacturer with a 31 December 2026 year-end, stable earnings for three years, and no debt covenant pressure. The auditor plans from prior-year actuals: pre-tax income of $2,400,000, total revenue of $40,000,000, and total assets of $30,000,000.

Pre-tax income is the most relevant benchmark because users focus on profit. 5% of pre-tax income is 0.05 times $2,400,000, which equals $120,000. The cross-checks run higher: 0.5% of revenue is 0.005 times $40,000,000, which equals $200,000, and 1% of total assets is 0.01 times $30,000,000, which equals $300,000. The auditor selects the lowest, $120,000, as overall materiality.

With good controls and few past adjustments, the auditor sets performance materiality at the upper end of the 50% to 75% range: 75%. 0.75 times $120,000 equals $90,000. The clearly trivial threshold is 5% of overall materiality: 0.05 times $120,000 equals $6,000, which is 6.67% of performance materiality, since $6,000 divided by $90,000 equals 6.67%. Tolerable misstatement for the accounts receivable sample is $60,000, below the $90,000 performance materiality, so it complies with AU-C 530.A3.

Performance Materiality and Tolerable Misstatement

Performance materiality is a lower working figure inside overall materiality, leaving room for small errors to add up, plus errors the audit never spots, without the combined total crossing overall materiality. The auditor sets it when sizing risk assessment and deciding the nature, timing and extent of further testing.

Aggregation explains it: individually immaterial misstatements can add up to a material one. Firms often pitch performance materiality at half to three quarters of overall materiality: near three quarters for a repeat audit with sound controls and few past corrections, near half for a first-year audit, weak controls, past adjustments or a high risk area.

Tolerable misstatement applies that working figure to one test, such as one sample or one account. AU-C 530 lets it match performance materiality or sit below it, never above it.

Practice guides commonly put the clearly trivial line at 3% to 5% of overall materiality. Anything unsure fails that test and counts as not clearly trivial.

Audit Materiality and Qualitative Factors That Override the Numbers

Whether an error matters turns on the setting around it, and on its size, its nature, or both together. SEC Staff Accounting Bulletin No. 99 warns against deciding materiality from a number alone, even the familiar 5% figure.

SAB 99 names several small errors that can still matter: one hiding a shift in earnings, one papering over a missed analyst forecast, one flipping a loss to a profit or the reverse, and one tied to fraud or a breach of the law.

Even a small deliberate error can still breach the books and records rules in the Securities Exchange Act of 1934.

Evaluating Uncorrected Misstatements Under AU-C 450

AU-C 450 tells the auditor to gather every error found, except plainly trivial ones. Errors fall into three groups: factual, spotted directly; judgmental, where the auditor disagrees with a management estimate; and projected, scaling up a sample finding to the whole population.

The auditor passes gathered errors to management and asks for fixes. Before judging uncorrected errors, the auditor checks whether the AU-C 320 materiality figure still fits actual results.

When the gathered total nears materiality, missed errors could take the true total past the line. When an uncorrected error is material yet leaves most of the statements reliable, the auditor generally gives a qualified opinion. When it is material and spreads through the statements, AU-C 705 generally calls for an adverse opinion.

Worked Example B: Aggregating Uncorrected Misstatements for Harborline Manufacturing Co.

Use the Example A thresholds: overall materiality of $120,000, performance materiality of $90,000, and a clearly trivial threshold of $6,000. During fieldwork the auditor finds four uncorrected misstatements, all overstating pre-tax income, which management declines to correct: inventory overstatement of $45,000; revenue cutoff error of $35,000; depreciation understated by $25,000; and projected misstatement in accounts receivable of $30,000.

Step 1 checks each item. $45,000, $35,000, $25,000 and $30,000 are each below overall materiality of $120,000 and below performance materiality of $90,000. Individually, none is material. Step 2 aggregates them. $45,000 plus $35,000 equals $80,000. $80,000 plus $25,000 equals $105,000. $105,000 plus $30,000 equals $135,000.

Step 3 compares the aggregate with overall materiality. $135,000 minus $120,000 equals $15,000. The aggregate exceeds overall materiality by $15,000, which is 12.5% above it, since $135,000 divided by $120,000 equals 1.125. Step 4 compares the aggregate with performance materiality. $135,000 minus $90,000 equals $45,000 above performance materiality, which uses up the margin for undetected misstatement.

Step 5 concludes. The financial statements are materially misstated in aggregate even though no single item is material. If management still refuses to correct the items, the auditor considers a qualified opinion, since the misstatement is material but not pervasive, under AU-C 705.

Step 6 handles the clearly trivial item. A separate $2,500 office supplies expense error is found. $2,500 is below the $6,000 clearly trivial threshold, so it is not accumulated.

PCAOB AS 2105: Audit Materiality for Issuer Audits

Issuer audits follow PCAOB AS 2105. For issuers, PCAOB AS 2105.06 asks the auditor to set one materiality figure for the statements as a whole, chosen to fit the company, including its earnings and other relevant facts. PCAOB wording drops performance materiality altogether: tolerable misstatement covers both jobs, and it must sit below overall materiality. Read it on the PCAOB site: PCAOB AS 2105.

Exam Traps: Audit Materiality Mistakes to Avoid

1. Mixing up tolerable misstatement and performance materiality. Performance materiality is the lower planning figure, set inside overall materiality. Tolerable misstatement applies it to one sample or account, at the same amount as performance materiality or lower.

2. Treating rules of thumb as rules. No percentage and no benchmark comes from AU-C 320 itself. The familiar figures, 5% of pre-tax income, 0.5% to 1% of revenue and 1% of total assets, are only rules of thumb.

3. Ignoring the qualitative side. An error under overall materiality can still count as material when it flips a loss to income, hides a shift in the earnings trend, covers up a covenant breach, or conceals fraud or a breach of the law.

4. Assuming materiality stays fixed after planning. Facts surfacing that would have changed the first figure call for revision under AU-C 320.12, and AU-C 320.13 then asks the auditor to revisit performance materiality and planned procedures when the revised figure is lower.

5. Mixing up clearly trivial and immaterial. Clearly trivial sits far below materiality, not just under it. Any doubt means the item is not clearly trivial, so it goes on the schedule.

6. Reading the 75 pass mark as 75% correct. Each section is reported on a 0-99 scale, with 75 as the pass mark. That 75 is scaled, so it is not 75% of questions right and not a percentile rank. AUD runs 4 hours, with 78 multiple-choice questions and 7 task-based simulations.

One-Page Revision Box

Term Amount or Rule
Overall materiality AU-C 320.10; $120,000 (5% of $2,400,000 pre-tax income)
Performance materiality $90,000 (75% of $120,000); range 50% to 75%
Tolerable misstatement Same as or lower than performance materiality; $60,000
Clearly trivial threshold $6,000 (5% of $120,000); range 3% to 5%
Evaluation AU-C 450: accumulate all except clearly trivial; $135,000 exceeds $120,000 by $15,000
Opinion Material but not pervasive: qualified; material and pervasive: adverse under AU-C 705

Redo Example A at 50% performance materiality and Example B with the $25,000 item corrected, then check each conclusion, then move on to the next note in the CPA notes hub.

Enjoying this? Add StudyFromNotes as a preferred source on Google to see our latest notes and updates more often:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *