Employee compensation CFA questions test two deferred forms of pay: pensions and share-based payments. The key distinction is who bears the risk. In a defined contribution plan the employee bears the investment risk, because the employer only promises fixed contributions. In a defined benefit plan the employer bears the risk, because the employer promises a specified benefit and funds any shortfall. Finally, employers measure share-based pay at grant date and spread it over the vesting period. More notes are at the CFA notes hub.
This note covers the CFA Level 1 module: defined contributions, defined benefits, and share-based compensation in Financial Statement Analysis. The Level 1 exam has 180 questions in two 135-minute sessions, while Financial Statement Analysis carries a 2026 weight of 11 to 14 percent. See the CFA financial statement analysis notes.
Employee compensation CFA: what the Level 1 module covers
Employee compensation CFA covers pensions and share-based payments. In a defined contribution plan the employee bears the investment risk, while in a defined benefit plan the employer bears it. IFRS is the default, with service cost plus net interest in profit or loss and remeasurements in other comprehensive income.
Employees earn deferred pay in one period and receive it later, and the amount may depend on future salary, years of service, or the share price. Specifically, IAS 19 governs employer pensions, not share-based payments. Similarly, IFRS 2 Share-based Payment governs share-based awards. US GAAP uses ASC 715 and ASC 718. Finally, IAS 26 covers the plan’s own statements.
Employee compensation CFA: defined contribution plans
In a defined contribution plan, the employer agrees to pay fixed contributions into a separate fund, with no duty to top up a shortfall. The employee bears the investment risk, so the retirement benefit depends on contributions plus investment returns. Consequently, expense equals the contribution due, an operating expense, with no PBO reported. Lastly, the balance sheet carries only unpaid or prepaid contributions.
Employee compensation CFA: defined benefit plans and funded status
A defined benefit plan promises a specified retirement benefit, often from final salary and service, while the employer bears the actuarial and investment risk. Specifically, the projected benefit obligation, or PBO, is the actuarial present value of benefits earned to date, using projected future salaries, discounted at high-quality corporate bond yields. Meanwhile, plan assets are investments in a separate pension trust. Similarly, both IFRS and US GAAP report funded status as plan assets minus the PBO. Assets above the obligation mean an overfunded plan and a net pension asset. Conversely, an obligation above assets means an underfunded plan and a net pension liability.
First, closing PBO equals opening PBO plus service cost plus interest cost minus benefits paid, adjusted for actuarial gains or losses. Next, interest cost equals opening PBO times the discount rate. Closing plan assets equal opening assets plus contributions plus actual return less benefits paid. Benefits paid cut both sides equally; contributions cut the net pension liability but are not an expense.
Employee compensation CFA: IFRS versus US GAAP pension expense
Under IFRS, IAS 19 has three components. First, service cost, including past service cost from a plan amendment, goes to profit or loss immediately. Next, net interest goes to profit or loss. It equals the discount rate times the opening net liability or asset. IFRS uses no expected return. Finally, remeasurements go to other comprehensive income, or OCI, and never return to profit or loss.
Under US GAAP, ASC 715 has five components. First, service cost goes to profit or loss in operating income. Next, interest cost goes to profit or loss outside operating income. Expected return reduces expense. Past service cost and actuarial gains and losses go to OCI first, then amortize into profit or loss.
| Component | IFRS (IAS 19) | US GAAP (ASC 715) |
|---|---|---|
| Service cost | Profit or loss | Profit or loss |
| Interest | Net interest at discount rate | Interest less expected return |
| Expected return | Not used | Reduces expense |
| Past service cost | Immediate, profit or loss | OCI, then amortized |
| Actuarial gains and losses | OCI, not recycled | OCI, then amortized |
| Balance sheet | Funded status | Funded status |
Worked example 1: defined benefit plan, expense and funded status
The example below uses hypothetical round inputs in US dollars. Opening PBO is $1,000 and opening plan assets are $800, so the plan opens underfunded by $200. The discount rate is 5 percent, expected return is 6 percent, service cost is $100, contributions are $120, benefits paid are $60, and actual return is $56. No actuarial gain or loss hits the PBO.
| Step | Calculation | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Opening status | $800 minus $1,000 | Net pension liability $200 |
| Interest cost | $1,000 x 5% | $50 |
| Interest income | $800 x 5% | $40 |
| Net interest | $50 minus $40 | $10 |
| IFRS expense | $100 plus $10 | $110 |
| Expected return | $800 x 6% | $48 |
| US GAAP expense | $100 plus $50 minus $48 | $102 |
| Closing PBO | $1,000 plus $100 plus $50 minus $60 | $1,090 |
| Closing plan assets | $800 plus $120 plus $56 minus $60 | $916 |
| Closing funded status | $916 minus $1,090 | Net pension liability $174 |
| Remeasurement gain | $56 minus $40 | $16 gain in OCI |
IFRS expense is $110 and US GAAP expense is $102, a difference of $8, because US GAAP uses a 6 percent expected return against the 5 percent discount rate. Closing PBO is $1,090 and closing assets are $916, so the closing funded status is a net pension liability of $174. Check: $200 plus $110 minus $120 minus $16 equals $174. Under US GAAP, $56 minus $48 is an $8 gain in OCI, and the liability is still $174.
Employee compensation CFA: share-based payments
Share-based pay aligns employee interests with shareholders while conserving cash. The main types are stock grants, including restricted stock, stock options, stock appreciation rights and phantom stock. Stock grants give the employee shares that vest only on meeting the conditions. In contrast, options give the right, not the obligation, to buy shares at a fixed exercise price after vesting. Stock appreciation rights and phantom stock settle in cash, so the employee receives cash, not shares.
With equity-settled awards, IFRS and US GAAP measure the award at fair value at the grant date and recognize that value as expense over the vesting period, usually straight-line. For stock grants, the market price usually sets fair value. For stock options, an option pricing model estimates fair value, because employee options have no traded market. Therefore, later share price changes leave the expense for equity-settled awards unchanged.
The other side is equity: retained earnings fall and paid-in capital rises, so total equity stays the same and no cash moves. The company estimates and revises the number of awards expected to vest, so expense reflects only the awards that actually vest. Grant-date fair value already prices in market conditions. Meanwhile, cash-settled awards form a liability, remeasured until settlement. Cash received on exercise is a financing inflow; the expense is non-cash.
Worked example 2: stock options with forfeitures
The example below is hypothetical. On 1 January Year 1, the company grants 10,000 stock options with a grant-date fair value of $6.00 per option. The exercise price equals the market price at the grant date, with 4-year cliff vesting (nothing vests until year 4) and straight-line expense. The forfeiture rate is 10 percent.
| Step | Calculation | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Total fair value | 10,000 x $6.00 | $60,000 |
| Annual expense before forfeitures | $60,000 / 4 | $15,000 per year |
| Options to vest | 10,000 x 90% | 9,000 options |
| Total expense after forfeitures | 9,000 x $6.00 | $54,000 |
| Annual expense after forfeitures | $54,000 / 4 | $13,500 per year |
| Cumulative after 2 years | $13,500 x 2 | $27,000 |
Each year: debit compensation expense $13,500, credit additional paid-in capital $13,500. If only 9,000 vest, total expense stays at $54,000. On exercise, if the holder exercises all 9,000 vested options at $20 per share, cash received is 9,000 times $20, or $180,000, recorded as a financing cash inflow.
Employee compensation CFA: exam traps to avoid
Contributions are not expense: they reduce the net pension liability.
IFRS uses net interest, not an expected return.
Under IFRS, actuarial gains and losses stay in OCI, while past service cost hits profit or loss at once.
Under US GAAP, both go to OCI first, then amortize into profit or loss.
Defined benefit risk sits with the employer, defined contribution risk with the employee.
The grant date fixes fair value for equity-settled awards; only cash-settled awards face remeasurement.
Expense spreads over vesting.
The PBO uses projected salaries, while the ABO (accumulated benefit obligation) uses current salaries.
Benefits paid cut the PBO and plan assets equally.
Share-based pay is non-cash at recognition; cash moves only on exercise or settlement.
IAS 26 covers the plan’s own statements, while the employer standard is IAS 19.
Lastly, the 11 to 14 percent weight covers the whole Financial Statement Analysis topic, not this module alone.
One page revision box
Revision: who bears the risk first, then IFRS versus US GAAP, then grant date.
Defined contribution: employee bears the risk.
Defined benefit: employer bears the risk, funded status is plan assets minus PBO.
IFRS: service cost plus net interest, remeasurements in OCI, never recycled.
US GAAP: service cost plus interest cost less expected return plus amortizations.
Example 1: IFRS $110, US GAAP $102, PBO $1,090, assets $916, liability $174, OCI $16 gain.
Share-based pay: fair value fixed at grant date, spread over vesting, forfeitures trued up.
Example 2: $60,000 total, $54,000 after forfeitures, $13,500 a year, $27,000 after 2 years.
Sources
CFA Institute Level I exam page (180 questions, two 135-minute sessions, FSA weight 11 to 14 percent).
Redo both worked examples from memory. More notes are at the CFA notes hub.
Enjoying this? Add StudyFromNotes as a preferred source on Google to see our latest notes and updates more often:

Lauren Brooks is a finance professional who writes about the CPA and CFA exams, study strategy, and global finance careers. Lauren has sat professional finance exams and builds notes from the official syllabus and exam blueprints, with worked examples and one-page revision boxes. The beat covers US and UK exam routes, interview preparation, and the study habits that carry candidates through long exam seasons.
Leave a Reply